Skip to main content

SICP: Broken Math

Here's a great little math trick from SICP:
v = 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + ...
Let's play around with that equation a bit:
v - 1 = 2 + 4 + 8 + ...
(v - 1) / 2 = 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + ...
But that's the same as the first line. Hence, we see that:
(v - 1) / 2 = v
Solving for v, we get:
v = -1
-1 = 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + ...
Crazy, eh? Sussman said:
Arguments that are based on convergence are flaky, if you don't know the convergence beforehand. You can make wrong arguments. You can make deductions as if you know the answer and not be stopped somewhere by some obvious contradiction.
I think the bad assumption in this case is thinking that some v could exist and be a normal integer. Clearly, there is no such normal integer v that equals 1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + ...

Comments

kib said…
Funny post,

Sussman is right, we have to be very careful when handling limits.

But for this one, it seems rather natural that v will not be an integer.
stan said…
Although, if you write a C program to evaluate that sum using signed integers, it does converge to -1. :)
Anonymous said…
Why do you call it a trick? Seems more like an anti-trick to me, if anything. As in, no, really, don't try this at home or anywhere else.
kib said…
A nice one was found by Gauss (it is said to, be maybe that's a legend...) when he was a child and asked to find this (finite) sum :

Sn = 1 + 2 + 3 + ... + n

Gauss started by writing the numbers like this :

Sn = 1 2 3 4 5 ... n

then in reversed order :
Sn = n n-1 n-2 2 1

What's the point ? He could now add each column and see that they all give n+1:

2*Sn = n+1 n+1 n+1 ... n+1

As with have n equal terms, 2*Sn is easily computed :
2*Sn = = n*(n+1)

So, Sn = n*(n+1)/2

Nice no ?!
jjinux said…
> Although, if you write a C program to evaluate that sum using signed integers, it does converge to -1. :)

Haha, I thought of that too ;)

> Why do you call it a trick?

I didn't know what else to call it ;)
jjinux said…
> A nice one was found by Gauss

Ah, yes, I know that story. The funny is when I showed my wife this "trick", she came up with the same story ;) So let me see:

n = infinity
(infinity (infinity - 1)) / 2 = infinity

(But note, it's the same "kind" of infinity, since there's a 1-1 mapping between the two.)
Anonymous said…
There is quite a theory about divergent series. Have you found http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divergent_series
where they give a bibliography, including a book by G. H. Hardy.

I think this particular sum is due to Euler.

Popular posts from this blog

Drawing Sierpinski's Triangle in Minecraft Using Python

In his keynote at PyCon, Eben Upton, the Executive Director of the Rasberry Pi Foundation, mentioned that not only has Minecraft been ported to the Rasberry Pi, but you can even control it with Python. Since four of my kids are avid Minecraft fans, I figured this might be a good time to teach them to program using Python. So I started yesterday with the goal of programming something cool for Minecraft and then showing it off at the San Francisco Python Meetup in the evening.

The first problem that I faced was that I didn't have a Rasberry Pi. You can't hack Minecraft by just installing the Minecraft client. Speaking of which, I didn't have the Minecraft client installed either ;) My kids always play it on their Nexus 7s. I found an open source Minecraft server called Bukkit that "provides the means to extend the popular Minecraft multiplayer server." Then I found a plugin called RaspberryJuice that implements a subset of the Minecraft Pi modding API for Bukkit s…

Apple: iPad and Emacs

Someone asked my boss's buddy Art Medlar if he was going to buy an iPad. He said, "I figure as soon as it runs Emacs, that will be the sign to buy." I think he was just trying to be funny, but his statement is actually fairly profound.

It's well known that submitting iPhone and iPad applications for sale on Apple's store is a huge pain--even if they're free and open source. Apple is acting as a gatekeeper for what is and isn't allowed on your device. I heard that Apple would never allow a scripting language to be installed on your iPad because it would allow end users to run code that they hadn't verified. (I don't have a reference for this, but if you do, please post it below.) Emacs is mostly written in Emacs Lisp. Per Apple's policy, I don't think it'll ever be possible to run Emacs on the iPad.

Emacs was written by Richard Stallman, and it practically defines the Free Software movement (in a manner of speaking at least). Stal…

JavaScript: Porting from react-css-modules to babel-plugin-react-css-modules (with Less)

I recently found a bug in react-css-modules that prevented me from upgrading react-mobx which prevented us from upgrading to React 16. Then, I found out that react-css-modules is "no longer actively maintained". Hence, whether I wanted to or not, I was kind of forced into moving from react-css-modules to babel-plugin-react-css-modules. Doing the port is mostly straightforward. Once I switched libraries, the rest of the port was basically:
Get ESLint to pass now that react-css-modules is no longer available.Get babel-plugin-react-css-modules working with Less.Get my Karma tests to at least build.Get the Karma tests to pass.Test things thoroughly.Fight off merge conflicts from the rest of engineering every 10 minutes ;) There were a few things that resulted in difficult code changes. That's what the rest of this blog post is about. I don't think you can fix all of these things ahead of time. Just read through them and keep them in mind as you follow the approach above.…